All stories about "The Critics: On The Page"

Thursday, May 8, 2008

Classic Gold: The Love/Hate of Father's Office

2008_05_fo2%20patio.jpg

Jonathan Gold takes a bite out of Father's Office 2.0 at the Helms Bakery complex in Culver City-adjacent, and the review (the food isn't quite there yet, but there are some interesting and delicious bites, and of course, the burger and beer are tops) is chock-full of classic Goldisms. To wit:

"With Father’s Office, which inspires the extremes of behavior often described by scientists studying overcrowded animal cages, there is no middle ground."

"Yoon could probably get away with serving his goat-cheese gratinée in telephone booths if he felt like it."

"...a table should be at least as easy to command as a parking space at the Grove the day after Thanksgiving — if you maintain the necessary levels of attention and aggression."

"I have heard from several sources that when Yoon visited Osteria Mozza and asked whether he could order the pasta tasting for just two people instead of for the entire table, as was printed on the menu, Nancy Silverton said: 'Only if you let me order a hamburger without cheese the next time I’m at your restaurant.'"

He's softened on the FO experience, maybe because finding a seat in the bigger, splashier location, though still difficult, isn't as bad as the SM original. From Gold's 2004 review: "Father's Office is a perfect analogue to Bush-era America, a closed, mean, inward-looking place where tyranny masquerades as freedom, cronyism is taken for granted, and the powers that be talk a lot about hamburgers but ultimately deliver pâté." Ouchers.
· All Hopped Up at The New Father's Office [LAW]
· Fight Club [LAW]
· Eater Inside: Father's Office 2.0 Debut [~ELA~]



Critic Showdown: Brix@1601

Two critics, one restaurant. This week both S. Irene Virbila and Jonathan Gold preview Brix@1601, a wine-centric restaurant that opened at the Hermosa Pavilion a few weeks ago. Miss Irene says Michael McDonald's food isn't breaking any barriers but it's good and well-executed. There's talk of sliders and steaks. Gold basically agrees, but also gives mad props to Caitlin Stansbury, "one of L.A.’s rock-star sommeliers, a whip-thin woman with the haunted eyes of a lead guitarist and the ability to make Greek rosés and South African syrahs seem like the most desirable liquids in the world." We took a quick look a few weeks ago, but there's nothing like a shiny new photo gallery to bring it all home. (1601 Pacific Coast Hwy, Hermosa Beach, 310.698.0740)
· First Look: Brix@1601 [LAT]
· Brix @ 1601: The Newest Home of Rock-Star Sommelier Caitlin Stansbury [LAW]
· Eater Inside: Brix@1601 [~ELA~]


Wednesday, May 7, 2008

Week in Reviews: Michael's on Naples, El Prado, South and More

This week S. Irene Virbila unearths a random Italian restaurant in Naples, the tony marina enclave in Long Beach. Michael's on Naples has all the right touches---sleek interior, rooftop deck with sea breezes, octopus carpaccio and handmade pastas from chef Marco Cavuoto, lots of Italian wines---and only a few hiccups (service is disorganized and not very professional, it's loud, "corny" Italian music). Her ambience note at the end of the review sums it up best:

Contemporary Italian in Naples with roomy booths and a stylish open-air rooftop dining area. Far outclasses anything else on the island and attracts an affluent, Italian-food-mad crowd.
So there's just not a lot of good food on Naples, and Michael's gets two stars. Miss Irene overhears a LB customer ask why should they trek to West Hollywood when they can walk to Michael's. Indeed. Someone from WeHo is probably asking themselves the same question about Naples in Long Beach. Today the "S." stands for "stolid." [LAT]

From around the blogosphere: El Prado, Fraiche, South, Amandine Patisserie and More >>

Thursday, May 1, 2008


Wednesday, April 30, 2008

Week in Reviews: Akasha, Amarone, Yum Cha Cafe, Father's Office Cocktails and MORE

2008_02_akasha%20dr.jpg

We expected a total S. Irene Virbila love-fest for Akasha, Akasha Richmond's uber-green restaurant in Culver City, and everything is something: eco-friendly uniforms, great space, lighting is just right, noise level is "spirited but manageable," there's a pizza she's ordered more than once, her friend got all "dreamy-eyed" over a vegetarian bowl with Punjab beans, desserts are delcious. So what gives?

With the main courses, the difficulty of the stretch from caterer to full-fledged restaurateur shows most. The execution can be uneven, too. Roast Rosie chicken tastes like a real chicken but looks like something you'd get from an amateur cook who doesn't have experience in plating or making food look attractive. Asian-style short ribs are cloying. Lamb osso buco is a mess on the plate, braised too long and its flavor drowned out in a strong reduction. It's $30, incidentally, and the short ribs are $29. At that price point, Richmond is playing in the big leagues, competing with Lucques, or with Fraîche down the street.
Ah, so that's why Akasha gets one-and-a-half stars. Miss Irene is "confident" the "fledgling restaurant with a strong point of view---and big dose of soul" will pull through. Today the "S." stands for "straightforward." [LAT]

Amarone Kitchen & Wine, new dim sum in Chinatown and more ELSEWHERE >>

Thursday, April 24, 2008


Wednesday, April 23, 2008

Week in Reviews: LA Mill Doubles, Father's Office Onslaught, Samurai Sam's, Dodgers Stadium, MORE

2008_01_LAMILL%20alen.jpg
Alen Lin, 1/14/08

S. Irene Virbila will follow "the extraordinary" Michael Cimarusti anywhere, and this week she takes in the Silver Lake coffee experiment known as LA Mill. Sure, she's wowed by the ceremony of the siphon, the Chemex, or the one-cup Clover wonder, but it's Cimarusti's, and pastry chef Adrian Vasquez's, menu that really gets her:

In fact, there's nothing usual about the place. As an adjunct to its coffee and teas, LA Mill serves food that outclasses any other cafe in town.

Sandwiches? We're not talking tuna fish or egg salad. Michael Cimarusti, the extraordinary chef behind Providence in L.A., devised the menu for LA Mill owner Craig Min. The deceptively casual food he's come up with makes LA Mill a destination not just for the exceptional coffee...The prosciutto panino is made with Reblochon, a cheese that takes well to warming in the panini press. And although $12 or $14 for a sandwich may sound outlandish for this once-funky neighborhood, the fact is, for what you're getting, it's a great value. The quality is there, and that sandwich is large enough to share.

She highlights soups, the frisee salad with coffee vinaigrette, the new dinner menu, Vasquez's passionfruit gelee with basil seeds, and doles out two stars. The Rubbish design, the presentation, the clientele with their MacBook Airs and designer baby carriages are just the things to make any non-local feel comfortable in "scruffy" Silver Lake. Today the "S." stands for "so boho." [LAT]

NEXT: Father's Office 2.0, The Waffle, Canter's at Dodgers Stadium, More Elsewhere >>

Thursday, April 17, 2008


Wednesday, April 16, 2008

Week in Reviews: Bond Street Zeroes Out, Providence, Fraiche, Noodle Shops, Little Cambodia and More

2008_02_bondst.jpg
Alen Lin, 1/22/08

The Los Angeles Times got our attention on the homepage: "Something's fishy in Beverly Hills. No stars for Bond Street." We can't say we're surprised. Sushi in trendy settings isn't S. Irene Virbila's forte; plus, she's on quite the tear these days. In a city where good sushi doesn't need stellar decor and designer uniforms, and the trendoids already have plenty of places to coo over, Jonathan Morr and the Bond Street chefs would really have to step it up. Oh how they did not impress:

After several evenings at Bond Street, I have a radical suggestion to make: Stay away from the raw fish and stick with salads, vegetables and main-course seafood and meat dishes. Your meal won't be inexpensive, but you won't come away as outraged.

This is a restaurant where sashimi comes two slices per order and where truffle butter, foie gras, pork belly, tarragon oil and other tricks of the new sushi chefs' trade embroider many dishes. Scallop carpaccio, for example, arrives looking very like an albino apple tart on an icy granita. "It's calamansi citrus granita," the server whispers as he sets the plate in front of us. This sounds as if it could be very delicious. Until I take a bite and find the raw scallop slice is funky and the granita is achingly sweet. I want to scrub off my tongue.

Right there we know this isn't a restaurant Miss Irene would normally even bother with, but she felt compelled. There are a few dishes that worked (seaweed salad, steak), so maybe that's what the crowds who flock there are eating. Maybe they're not eating at all. Maybe that's not the point. We don't know the last time Miss Irene doled out no stars (damn new LAT search), but there it is. Today the "S." stands for "scorched." [LAT]

NEXT: Fraiche, Providence, Little Tokyo and Little Cambodia, more >>

Friday, April 11, 2008


Thursday, April 10, 2008


Wednesday, April 9, 2008

Week in Reviews: Citrus at Social Triples, The Waffle, LA Mill, La Buca and MORE

2008_02_citrus%20DR.jpg
Photo by Alen Lin, 2/08

Today we have S. Irene Virbila's semi-glowing review of Citrus at Social, otherwise known as the Michel Richard/Jeffrey Chodorow show. Citrus is Richard's big return to Los Angeles, although "return" is relative since the chef mainly lends his menu and cleverly named dishes to the capabable hands of an on-the-ground team led by chef Remi Lauvand. In her eyes, Chodorow is brilliant for bringing in a chef who's name "has resonance in LA" and creating "the most glamorous room in all of L.A. at the moment." But is it enough?

Cuttlefish carbonara is another tour de force, which makes Nobu's famous squid "pasta" seem clumsy in comparison. No noodles are involved. Instead, it's tender, sweet cuttlefish cut to resemble fettuccine -- a subtle ode to texture. Escargots is so rich it's better to share than eat all yourself; it's something like an escargots crumble, with the earthy nuggets disposed in three small crocks, each topped with mixed chopped nuts in a parsley sauce.

Lauvand is turning out very polished food at Citrus at Social. Big question: Will the coterie of fine diners from the Westside make it this far east on a regular basis? And will the condominiums and the W Hotel going up in Hollywood be built in time to save the day? From the looks of it, they don't seem to be turning the tables much, even on the weekends.

Miss Irene gives Citrus three stars, but it seems to be more a direct homage to Richard and his menu than the restaurant itself. Service is genial, but the hosts made her wait at the bar when she was on time and gave her the "worst table" in the house---automatic star dockers anywhere else. (She did get the best table on her second visit. Shocking.) And the crowd is as mixed as expected, with both a parade of "metrosexuals with cocky hats" and older diners, AKA the Richard fan club. Today the "S." stands for "social experiment." [LAT]

The Waffle isn't as bad as everyone says, brunch at Murano and more >>

Thursday, April 3, 2008

Miss Irene Goes to Vegas Part Deux: Payard, "Bargain" Dining at Guy Savoy

2008_04_payard.jpg
Payard at Caesars Palace

Every now and again, the Los Angeles Times sends S. Irene Virbila to wine and dine at the resorts in Vegas because, you know, there aren't enough places to cover in LA. She doesn't write reviews, per se, but she definitely doles it out, Miss Irene-style. Yesterday, it was all about the Palazzo restaurants---Batali's Carnevino, Wolfgang Puck's new Cut, Restaurant Charlie from Charlie Trotter, and Emeril Lagasse's Table 10. Today, we have Miss Ireneisms from the rest, and in truth, she picks some winners: breakfast at Payard, oysters at Bouchon, and bargain dining at Lotus of Siam and Guy Savoy, if a $75 glass of Champagne at Guy Savoy is a bargain to you. "Budget" dining is in the eye of the wallet-holder, that's for sure.

Payard Patisserie and Bistro at Caesars Palace:
"Breakfast here is sheer poetry. For a mere $16, you get good, strong coffee, fresh-squeezed orange juice and as many of Payard's exquisite morning pastries as you can devour in one sitting. That means a croissant so buttery and flaky, you and the table are covered in crumbs at the first bite. You'd be hard-pressed to find one anywhere in Paris (I mean the real Paris) of this caliber."

Bargains: Authentic Thai and great wine list, $75 glass of Champagne, more >>



Wednesday, April 2, 2008

Week in Reviews: The Hall at Palihouse, The Waffle, The Hungry Cat, Creperie by Jack 'n Jill's and MORE

2008_03_The%20hall%20palihouse.jpg

The Hall at Palihouse probably isn't one of the places S. Irene Virbila's readers put at the top of their must-do list, but she braved the stylish brasserie to tell them: Don't bother. It's not that people aren't going---actors, actresses, those who aren't really eating the food, are there. And it's not that chef Stephanie O'Mary's menu is all bad; there are a few hits. It's just that Miss Irene is generally disenchanted:

Chef O'Mary's handmade agnolotti have a delicious, deep-flavored kabocha squash filling. And the thick-cut baby lamb chops -- two of them -- served with a little olive tapenade make a strange first course, but order them as a light main course. They're beautifully cooked a true medium rare and very tender.

[But]…

If you've ordered the skate wing or loup de mer, you're bound to be sorely disappointed. My skate wing is tired when it should be pristinely fresh. Whole loup de mer is a tiny fellow, overcooked, and with a funky taste. For another main course, a trio of seared scallops sits on top of shredded short ribs. The whole thing is just awful.

She assumes the crowd isn't that much into the food anyway ("Guests pick at their plates desultorily, but they're mostly talking.") because the room and patio have a nice ambience, the lighting is good, the staff "endearing" and "affable." It's just not enough: The Hall gets a half a star. Today the "S." stands for "shot down." [LAT]

Creperie, the Hungry Cat, Waffle and more ELSEWHERE >>

Thursday, March 27, 2008


Wednesday, March 26, 2008

Week in Reviews: Little Dom's Does Little, FOOD, Tomato Pie and MORE

2008_02_Little%20doms%20dr.jpg
Alen Lin, 1/31/08

S. Irene Virbila likes just about everything about Little Dom's in Los Feliz---the decor, the vibe, the capable, confident service, the eclectic crowd---she's just not that into the food. But Warner Ebbink and chef Brandon Boudet's Dominick's off-shoot is "barely 3 months old," so she's hopeful:

Little Dom's comes on strong with its look and old-school Italian vibe. And with its moderate prices, this Los Feliz newcomer is poised to become a lively neighborhood hang. But the food at this Dominick's spinoff isn't quite there yet. Dominick's shows it's possible to turn out lusty Italian American fare at this price point. The kitchen here may just need some time to pull it all together. Meanwhile, there's the rice balls, the grilled artichoke and that wood-grilled burger. And for plenty of hipsters, that's quite enough.
We thought restaurants didn't get reviewed until after three months, so, sure, Little Dom's probably needs more time. But the constant crowds really don't seem to mind. One star for Little Dom's. Today the "S." stands for "too soon." [LAT]

FOOD, Tomato Pie, Hatfield's, Roy's and more ELSEWHERE >>

Monday, March 24, 2008

LA Magazine's Top 75 Restaurants, Now Starred!

2008_03_lamag75.jpg

There are a lot of interesting food reads in the April issue of Los Angeles magazine (the Zankou murders, meeting industry insiders like the founder of Chefwear), but we must start with the biggest, boldest move on the food editors/writers' part: Coming up with a list of the 75 best restaurants in LA and implementing a brand-spanking new star system. The magazine, and we assume this goes for Patric Kuh's full reviews, never used stars because, the editors say, "it narrowed our options by influencing us to review restaurants based on a system rather than a sense of exploration." Now these stars (one through four) "puts perspective into opinion and grounds it in fact." In all honesty, we kind of liked that LAM didn't star restaurants. It wasn't difficult to discern what Kuh thought about a place; it almost always seemed/sounded even-handed. Now it's one more rating to clump in with the LA Times and Angeleno, the only two notable locals to use stars, not to mention the various Yelp and Citysearch ratings (which mean less since they're weighted and fiddled with by algorithms), all of which really just allow the restaurants more marketing verbage ("#1 four-star restaurant in LA!"). Then again, by definition, these ratings make sense:

****: "Remarkable and extraordinary"
***: "Bold and ambitious"
**: "Distinctive and assured"
*: "Pleasant and satisfying"

As long as everything fits the new ratings, it should work. This is important now because the editors grouped the 75 top LA restos by star and in descending order. Number one four star, top of the heap: Lucques, Suzanne Goin and Caroline Styne's nearly 10-year-old restaurant. The rest of the list (really 76 because the Mozzas are two different restaurants but grouped as one) to follow.

Continue reading "LA Magazine's Top 75 Restaurants, Now Starred!"



Thursday, March 20, 2008


Wednesday, March 19, 2008

Week in Reviews: Wilshire Triples, The Waffle, Goat and More Elsewhere

The headline for today's LAT review is somewhat confusing: "Wilshire restaurant reinvents itself as a serious dining destination." Chef Christopher Blobaum was nothing if not serious, which might have been the problem; he left in February after his and the owner's vision no longer meshed, and chef de cusine Andrew Kirschner took over, starting his menu this month. Somewhere between then and now, S. Irene Virbila finds Wilshire finally hitting its stride.

Come warm weather, this is going to be the place to be. And just in time. With tensions easing, Wilshire is less dysfunctional. Kirschner's assured, effortless-seeming cooking is a breath of fresh air. He's blessed with not only a good palate, but also a good eye. And he can execute, which makes him a triple threat.
The restaurant is more than two years old, and the nightlife vibe it had in the beginning has softened. No matter how good a chef or service is, when Miss Irene starts a review complaining about scantily clad women and being seated in "Siberia," as she did with the 2005 review, a restaurant really has to work to redeem itself. And Wilshire has: It gets an extra star taking it to three, something we haven't seen in these parts for awhile. Today the "S." stands for "shake up." [LAT]

Goat, Richie's Pizza, Coupa Cafe, The Oinkster and more ELSEWHERE >>

Thursday, March 13, 2008

Week in Reviews: LA Mill

2008_03_lamill.jpg

Jonathan Gold is completely enthralled with what LA Mill brings to the collective dining-scene table, whatever that may be:

"The past few months have seen a lot of fascinating new restaurants open in Los Angeles, but the most interesting of them all may be a coffee shop in the restaurant-starved heart of Silver Lake, a place whose menu is designed by Providence’s Michael Cimarusti and Adrian Vasquez, and whose owners are devoted to the cult of coffee in the same way that a chapel might be dedicated to its saint.

It’s hard, in fact, to figure out exactly what La Mill might be — a lunchroom, a tearoom, a café, or a wine bar serving aged Sumatran peaberry instead of Bordeaux. What is clear is that no brew-pub impresario, no sushi master is more serious about his product than La Mill’s self-styled “Coffee Savant” Eton Tsuno, its equivalent of a rock-star sommelier."

The fact that even Mr. Gold can't completely define, in simple terms, LA Mill, is one reason why so many people were so annoyed with it in the beginning. This is conceptual, gourmet, even cerebral coffee, which doesn't fly when you just want a good cup of joe to go.
· LA Mill: The Latest Buzz [LA Weekly]




Wednesday, March 12, 2008

Week in Reviews: The Range Near SLO, STK, La Fonda, Luckyfish and MORE

We're all for finding new restaurants in Central Coast wine country, but even S. Irene Virbila surprises us with this random pick. She heads way north---Santa Margarita, a few miles north of San Luis Obispo---to try The Range, a good country restaurant with cowboy sensibilities. Nothing revolutionary, just good:

On a weeknight, the place is half full, yet the chef and owner, Jeff Jackson, isn't cutting back. The waitress recites the four specials that night with real appreciation in her voice. She knows they're good. But I've already spotted crawfish cakes on the menu. Steak with red-eye gravy? For sure. A homey tomato bisque, wild arugula salad and seafood risotto. Sounds good. It all sounds good.
Everything's just so darn good, it's about the only adjective she can find (at least 10 times) to describe many things, from the French onion soup to the beet salad to the wine list. The tucked-away, mostly locals-only restaurant is so good it gets two stars. Today the "S." stands for "strange." [LAT]

NEXT: Akasha, Luckyfish, Big Sugar Bakeshop and more ELSEWHERE >>

Thursday, March 6, 2008


Wednesday, March 5, 2008



Week in Reviews: Bar Pintxo, The Waffle, Craft and More

2008_01_Bar%20Pintxo%20front.jpg
Alen Lin, 1/25/08

S. Irene Virbila feels the need to school all the detractors about Joe Miller's Bar Pintxo: Tapas are single servings to nibble on, not big portions for multi-course dining, and just drink the Spanish wines. This all said with a heavy dose of "quit your bitching" sensed between words. As much as Miss Irene appreciates Miller's attempts at running an almost traditional tapas bar, she has her quibbles with portions:

His seem oversized compared with Spanish versions. It's as if he wants to pile enough stuff on top that he can charge $4 or $5 each. (He's got serious overhead, more probably than a typical tapas bar in Spain has to float.) And it's these real tapas -- pieces of bread topped with chorizo, tuna salad or tomato -- that are the least satisfying items on the menu, oddly enough, though I do like the simple and classic grilled bread rubbed with fresh tomato and topped with serrano ham.
If you must eat a meal, get the paella, a seat at the bar and sip and nibble. And by the way, the bar stools inside are indeed uncomfortable, but they weren't designed for marathon dining. Bar Pintxo gets one-and-a-half stars. [LAT]

Checking in at The Waffle, Craft, Aunti Em's and more ELSEWHERE >>

Friday, February 29, 2008


Thursday, February 28, 2008






Wednesday, February 27, 2008

Week in Reviews: Paperfish Sinks, Vegan Goodness at Akasha, Little Dom's, Brownstone Pizza and MORE

2007_12_Paperfish%20al%20bar.jpg
Inside 12/1/07, Alen Lin

When was the last time Joachim Splichal earned less than one star? Honestly, we can't think of one. No top dog is in every kitchen that has his or her name on it. Fact. But when Paperfish opened at the end of '07, Splichal was around to smooth out rough edges. Not enough, according to S. Irene Virbila. Whether chef de cuisine Yianni Koufodontis isn't ready for a Patina Group stage, or the Patina Group finally lost its Patina luster, something's not working:

The execution is inconsistent. One night almost every dish is too salty. Chestnut soup has a skin on it. Fried oysters are tepid. Another time, the cooking is crisper, but only just. Sauces are over-reduced and sweet; the rice is almost inedible, it's so unevenly cooked. Is it simply a bad match between the chef and Splichal's signature California-French cuisine?

It's more than that. With the possible exception of Patina at Walt Disney Concert Hall and Leatherby's Cafe Rouge in Costa Mesa, the cooking at outposts in the Patina empire doesn't have much of a personal stamp. The food is so anonymous it could be mistaken for a hotel or corporate restaurant's. In fact, Paperfish is a corporate restaurant, just one of the 20-something restaurants Splichal's Patina Restaurant Group owns and runs.

Miss Irene liked Koufodontis when he was at Petros, but for Splichal: "You'd think that for his return to Beverly Hills and the Westside after an absence of 22years…Splichal could do better than this -- much better." Paperfish gets half a star. Today the "S." stands for "slamalicious." (A shout out to wine guru Bonnie Graves pictured in the story.) [LAT]

NEXT: Akasha in Culver City, Brownstone Pizza in Eagle Rock and More Elsewhere >>





LA Links



About Eater LA
Eater LA is a blog that covers the Los Angeles restaurant, bar and nightlife scene. From the newest hotspots to the historic rock clubs on the Strip, Eater LA has you covered. Read more about Eater LA...

Tipping Is Customary
Know about a restaurant opening or closing in your neighborhood, or other LA scene gossip? Let's hear it.

Full content feed



photos in Eater LA Photo Pool See more and submit to Eater LA Photo Pool

Eater LA
Editor
Lesley Balla

Los Angeles Editor
Dakota Smith

Eater Eds-in-Chief
Ben Leventhal
Lockhart Steele

Photographer
Alen Lin

Banner Design
Jim Cooke

Publisher/GM
Kyle Crafton

Head of Technology
Eliot Shepard

Contact Us
Email Eater LA

elapsed: 1.111s | for: 38.103.63.16 | in 1 attempts